Hello, world of hypocrisy! The first idea that
struck my mind was the amount of hypocrisy demonstrated in this play! It just
seems like every character in the play was a hypocrite, one way or another.
We have Oronte, who was so eager to befriend
Alceste, spoke nice words to Alceste and asked Alceste for opinions regarding
his sonnet. But right after Alceste critiqued on his sonnet, he turned his back
on Alceste and filed a lawsuit against Alceste to seek for revenge.
We also have Arsinoe, who claimed that she
stood side with Celimene when other people talked about Celimene’s flirtatious behavior
but she revealed Celimene’s love letter to Oronte in attempt to destroy Alceste
and Celimene’s relationship.
Another very obvious character who was a
hypocrite was Celimene. She turned her house/salon into a gossip shack. She was
young, outgoing, affectionate, and sociable; she had all the personalities
required to be under the spotlight and the center of attention which attracted
a lot of admirers. She flirted with all her suitors and spoke kind words to
them. However, she lied to Alceste that he was her one true love. She was like the ‘mean
girl’ who pretended to be nice in front of everybody but spoke nastily about
them behind their backs.
While reading through the play, I thought that
Alceste was the just and noble one who separated himself from the hypocritical
society. He even hated the human race for their two-faced behavior ("Some men I hate for being rogues; the
others/ I hate because they treat the rogues like brothers" ).But wait…
He claimed that he hated people for their insincerity but he still professed
his love to Celimene when he knew about her actual personalities. He was condemning and
insulting people for being ‘fake’ but calling his own hypocritical behavior ‘love’.
What’s worse, he even asked Celimene to become a hypocrite by telling her to "Pretend, pretend, that you are just
and true,/And I shall make myself believe in you".
Well, while the ending of the
play seemed to oppose the hypocrites: Alceste was in isolation,
Celimene was abandoned by her suitors; Philinte and Eliante had a happy ending.
I was a little confused at first because all this while I thought that the entire play was opposing hypocrisy by
placing Alceste as the protagonist. But now to me the ending just suggested that a little
hypocrisy is acceptable in the society. Philinte disliked Oronte’s sonnet but
he did not throw direct insult at Oronte. Real world needs a little white lies
and flatteries to live in.
I really like how you broke down each aspect of hypocrisy in the play. It is totally accurate. But since you say a little hypocrisy is acceptable that begs the question: How much is a little? Where do we draw the line?
ReplyDeleteSerene, you hit at an important aspect of the text: Alceste is trying to save society from itself by stamping out hypocrisy, which undermines the whole idea of social interactions. How can we know what anyone thinks if they act so hypocritically all the time? As Emily asks, it is difficult to know where the middle way lies between total hypocrisy and no hypocrisy...it's all about balance and elasticity (hello, Bergson!)
ReplyDelete