At this point, we've watched a couple
plays and read many more. As we discussed the difference in drama
and theater in our last class, I felt like now was a good time to
bring up differences in watching a play and reading a play, and why
ultimately I believe reading a play is certainly not the best way to
experience one.
In most of the plays we've read, hardly
anything except dialogue is mentioned. With nothing much else to go
on, reading a play feels a lot like looking at a template. By
reading a play we can understand its intentions, but so much is lost
when a play isn't viewed. Certain character's tones can be
misinterpreted, I know on more than one occasion in this and other
classes I've been totally wrong about how a character was approaching
a situation just because I didn't pick it up from how it was
presented in the play. The Beaver Coat is
the first play to actually mitigate things like this, being very
descriptive in the way people look, act, and speak.
When I
say much is lost in only reading a play, I don't just mean
better visualizing what's occurring, but the play's character. While
that in itself might not be relevant to analysis in our class, it
doesn't change the fact that some of my favorite parts from the plays
we've watched have been things that were never explicitly mentioned
in text alone. In The Venetian Twins,
my favorite thing is when Tanino (Zanetto?) is giving an aside and
one of the servants squints over his shoulder to try to see who he's
talking to. In The Broken Jug,
Judge Adam breaking his stick (it just snaps in half as he's banging
it, it doesn't look like it was even intentional) was one of the few
things that made me laugh.
In the
end I believe it is unfortunate that more of these plays aren't
watched instead of read, as they were intended.
I mostly agree. I like reading plays because I can imagine the characters how I want to and not just how they are chosen by some director. However, I do like being able to see all the different action that is never written in the text.
ReplyDelete