When
I first read the ending, I was shocked, but after a few minutes, I was like “YEA!
Go Mathilde von Zahnd! Mess up their plans! Show those physicists that they are
the fools!” I accepted the ending even though it’s not like a regular comedic
ending with unity at the end. The ending was filled with despair and no unity
as all three physicists went into their own little soliloquy of who they were
and walked back hopelessly into their rooms. I believe Mobius and the other
physicists deserved such an ending. They tried to “save” humanity from
destruction, but they did so in a despicable fashion. Although Mathilde von
Zahnd is a bit of a nutter for believing in King Solomon, her actions were the
punishment that the physicists deserved in the end.
First
off, all of them murdered a nurse. Even though these nurses were really working
for Fraulein von Zahnd, they were still human beings. In act two, the
physicists (Mobius, Eisler, and Kilton) finally toast to the nurses’ death.
They decide to keep themselves (and their knowledge-filled minds) hidden in the
sanatorium of Les Cerisiers in order to avoid the destruction of humanity so
that the nurses will not have died in vain. Murder is already a morally wrong
deed, but how dare they be so arrogant as to choose who dies in order to “save
humanity”?!! It’s also ironic how they’re trying to save humanity, yet they
themselves take human lives. I understand if they think some humans must be
sacrificed for the “greater good,” but why couldn’t they have committed
suicide? That’s a solution that would keep their knowledge/discoveries away
from the outside world, and it wouldn’t involve murder of other people. They deserved a
hopeless ending for their repulsive act of murder and believing they were doing
it for a good reason.
Secondly,
Mobius definitely deserved such a miserable ending. I know, I know: he believes
his discoveries will be the destruction of humanity, and he had to handle it
himself. Well, that does NOT excuse him from being a good father and husband
(at least in my opinion it does not). He put his poor wife thru years of hard
work just to sustain him and his sons (that lazy bum). I believe if a person
brings a child into this world, it is not only his/her partner’s responsibility
but his/her responsibility too. He could have at least exploited two or three
discoveries to earn some money (like Fraulein von Zahnd did) to give to his
wife and kids. Mobius definitely deserved such an ending because he abandoned
his responsibilities to financially support his family.
In
conclusion, the ending for the physicists was well-deserved for their
despicable actions. Yes, I understand they were trying to do it to save
humanity from being destroyed by Mobius’s discoveries. However, I don’t believe
they needed to murder anyone or abandon their families in order to do that. Slightly
going off in a tangent, in “21 Points to the Physicists”, it says, “Each
attempt of an individual to resolve for himself what is the concern of everyone
is doomed to fail.” Perhaps, if the physicists shared their concerns with the
world, there might be a group of people that would side with them and spread
their belief of preserving humanity. Also, if humanity IS all about destruction
and using knowledge against each other, then maybe humanity deserves to go extinct
for being so savage.
wow wow wow, what a post! I agree on your take that it's very despicable that they had to sacrifice OTHER lives to save the humanity. But when Newton and Einstein murdered the nurses, they were afraid that the nurses might discovered their identities of being spies. They faked their identities because they wanted Mobius to join their sides, not because they really cared about the whole humanity issue. Well, at least not until Mobius confronted and persuaded them that the secret had to be kept.
ReplyDeleteThis post is excellent. I think they deserved it too. I had never thought about the fact that they were deciding who gets to live or die. Now I think they are even more devious than I did before.
ReplyDelete